- The Dispatch
- Posts
- Pay rent or pay loans? Student borrowers are forced to choose.
Pay rent or pay loans? Student borrowers are forced to choose.
A new study found that many can't afford to make loan payments as the cost of living rises.

Photo illustration by Mendy Kong/WBEZ
A note from me: I’m sending this last newsletter of the year a bit early before everyone takes off for the holidays. Wishing you and yours a good one! See you next year! 🎄
An “unprecedented number” of student loan borrowers are poised to default as the cost of living rises, according to a new survey from The Institute for College Access and Success.
More than four in ten borrowers report making tradeoffs between loan payments and covering their basic needs, and 37% say their loans have hurt their ability to cover health care costs for themselves or their family, the survey found.
📚Read more: Debt with no degree: Indy student loan borrowers who don’t graduate face unique challenges (via our partner Mirror Indy)
One in five borrowers report their loans are currently in delinquency or default — meaning they are behind on payments — including one-third of people with some college but no degree. (The survey was of 1,010 borrowers, and responses were collected in September 2025.)
‘Fewer resources than ever’
“Ultimately, borrowers today have fewer resources than ever to navigate their repayment options, and those options are ever shifting,” Michele Zampini, associate vice president for federal policy and advocacy at TICAS, wrote in a blog post late last week.
📚 Read more: Chicagoans with student debt stressed as Trump, GOP cut back relief (via our partner WBEZ)
Zampini pointed to the Trump administration’s move to gut the Education Department and lay off hundreds of experts in the Office of Federal Student Aid. Loan servicers are also struggling to comply with changes to the repayment system, Zampini added.
Congress overhauled student loan repayment in the One Big Beautiful Bill Act over the summer. They eliminated access to all existing income-based repayment plans and replaced them with a plan that raises payments for most borrowers and extends the maximum repayment term to 30 years from the current 10-25 years. The law also eliminated deferment and forbearance options for borrowers facing financial hardship.
📚 Read more: How Ohio student loan borrowers are trying to navigate Trump administration’s repayment program changes (via our partner Signal Ohio)
“Taken together, these changes will likely make it harder for low- and middle-income borrowers to keep up with their monthly payments, which could lead to increased delinquency and default rates once they go into effect,” Zampini wrote.
SAVE settlement could make situation worse
Yesterday the Trump administration reached a settlement with several states over the SAVE program, a Biden-era student loan relief effort. As part of the settlement, the Education Department won’t enroll any new borrowers in SAVE and will deny pending applications.
Alexander Lundrigan, higher education policy and advocacy manager at the advocacy organization Young Invincibles, pointed to the TICAS survey in comments panning the settlement.
“At a time when everyone is talking about the cost of living, this administration eliminated the most affordable repayment plan in history,” he said. “Data shows we are headed toward mass default rates in the near future. Without an affordable repayment option, the situation will only get worse.”
The more than 7 million borrowers currently enrolled in SAVE will face higher monthly payments and could lose out on progress toward loan forgiveness, Zampini said in a statement yesterday. The settlement creates uncertainty for borrowers and leaves key questions unanswered, she said.
In 2025, Open Campus seeded and supported local reporting on the Trump administration's effort to reshape higher education institutions in communities across the country.
If you find our coverage helpful in navigating the shifting landscape of higher ed, please consider making a gift today.
From now until the end of the year, longtime Open Campus donors will match your new monthly donation 12 times or double your one-time gift, up to $1,000.
Elsewhere on Open Campus

Youngstown State University (Amy Morona/Signal Ohio)
From Ohio: Amy Morona, our reporter at Signal Ohio, featured Ronald Domen, a 1972 Youngstown State University alumnus who had planned to make a $100,000 gift to the university — until the state enacted a Florida-style higher-ed reform package.
The law requires faculty to publicly post their syllabi; bans faculty strikes; and creates new curriculum requirements. Domen sees it as “one group of people running around telling another group how to learn things and how to be educated and what books they can read.”
It’s just one example of the ripple effect of the law, which is yet another example of state legislators exerting influence over public universities. The university foundation declined to comment.
From North Carolina: Black students feel unwelcome at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, Brianna Atkinson reported at our partner WUNC. Enrollment of Black students has declined — junior Samuel Scarborough said he’s now sometimes the only Black student in his classes.
Over the summer the university closed a lounge where the Black Student Movement gathered. Administrators said it the move was necessary to comply with federal guidelines but students say it adds to their isolation.
“That’s a problem that people feel less encouraged to find community at Carolina,” said UNC-Chapel Hill’s student body president, Adolfo Alvarez. “That just does the whole opposite of what colleges are built for.”
Keep in touch
We’re a nonprofit newsroom that relies on the support of readers like you. Donate today.
Interested in reaching readers who care about higher education in communities across the country? Get in touch or request our media kit.
Please share. Forward this newsletter to colleagues, family, and friends who might be interested. They can sign up for their own copy here.
Run a newsroom and want to improve your coverage of higher ed? Let’s talk.
Got a story tip or a question? Please send it along.
What did you think of today's issue? |